Stoic philosophy and a Catholic critique
traditioninaction
Stoic philosophy
The Stoic school of philosophy was founded by Zeno of Citium about 300 BC, and is named after the stoa or porch in Greek, from which Zeno taught. It was strongly concerned with ethics. It taught that life must be in conformity with right reason, that man must attain a state of complete apathy and release from emotions, and that the truly wise man is, thus, free from evil because he is indifferent to anything that befalls him.
The Stoic school of philosophy was founded by Zeno of Citium about 300 BC, and is named after the stoa or porch in Greek, from which Zeno taught. It was strongly concerned with ethics. It taught that life must be in conformity with right reason, that man must attain a state of complete apathy and release from emotions, and that the truly wise man is, thus, free from evil because he is indifferent to anything that befalls him.
Stoicism was also a monistic and gnostic philosophy because it believed
that there was one principle spirit of the universe that permeated
nature. This world-spirit was believed to be a material god made up of a
fiery breath, called pneuma or soul of the world, that infused all creatures with heat and life.
Once the cycle of creation had taken its course, the pneuma would consume the world with fire and restart the cycle of events all over again. Each cycle was identical to the last as each played out the divine plan of the world-spirit. Thus the stoic philosophy was materialist, monist and fatalist. Not even spirits were immaterial, as these were also descended from the fiery body of the first principle; the pneuma.
Once the cycle of creation had taken its course, the pneuma would consume the world with fire and restart the cycle of events all over again. Each cycle was identical to the last as each played out the divine plan of the world-spirit. Thus the stoic philosophy was materialist, monist and fatalist. Not even spirits were immaterial, as these were also descended from the fiery body of the first principle; the pneuma.
As the pneuma controls and governs
the universe according to its own divine reason, so nature itself is
rational. Anything that happens is a pre-ordained event that is in
accordance with the divine dictates of this nature-fate. Thus, the stoic
god was immanent in creation and nothing that could happen was against
the divine will. It is, therefore, according to “nature” that we have
the health or wealth that we have and it is equally according to
nature-fate if we should lose them.
Evil, as such, only originates when we are overwhelmed by our emotions, giving way to passions that are disobedient to reason. Passions arise only from false judgments of what is good or bad. Unhappiness only comes when we desire that which we cannot have or reject that which we cannot avoid. Hence the virtuous and wise man should not be manipulated by his passionate reaction to things, but rather subject his emotions to reason, gladly accepting the decrees of fate.
Whether the soul of the world called a man to be surrounded by pleasures or tortured to death, whatever happens is appropriate to the rational design of the universe. Thus, the wise man should be indifferent and accept the things over which he has no control, letting his soul live in conformity to the divine plan of the universe.
The stoic, therefore, sought happiness not through the amassing of pleasures, but through living in conformity with the design of the universal being, the soul of the world or pneuma. This was believed to be the height of stoic virtue: to be above passions, to receive pain as readily as pleasure, and to calmly and rationally withhold assent from false judgments, accepting whatever fate sends you.
Evaluation & influence
Evil, as such, only originates when we are overwhelmed by our emotions, giving way to passions that are disobedient to reason. Passions arise only from false judgments of what is good or bad. Unhappiness only comes when we desire that which we cannot have or reject that which we cannot avoid. Hence the virtuous and wise man should not be manipulated by his passionate reaction to things, but rather subject his emotions to reason, gladly accepting the decrees of fate.
Whether the soul of the world called a man to be surrounded by pleasures or tortured to death, whatever happens is appropriate to the rational design of the universe. Thus, the wise man should be indifferent and accept the things over which he has no control, letting his soul live in conformity to the divine plan of the universe.
The stoic, therefore, sought happiness not through the amassing of pleasures, but through living in conformity with the design of the universal being, the soul of the world or pneuma. This was believed to be the height of stoic virtue: to be above passions, to receive pain as readily as pleasure, and to calmly and rationally withhold assent from false judgments, accepting whatever fate sends you.
Evaluation & influence
The stoics imagined that the spirit of fire – their god – was immanent in everything in the universe
Though not many of their writings survive, the stoics had a powerful
effect on the ancient Greek and Roman world. In truth. there were some
good and healthy elements of Stoicism, such as the patient endurance of
suffering, the subduing of the passions, the acceptance of the hardships
of life and the disregard of earthly pleasures as a means of happiness.
As a pagan philosophy, it attained thus a certain degree of
righteousness, but was still riddled through with errors.
Stoicism is inherently flawed, both in its immanent conception of God as a world spirit and in its denial of emotions as legitimate responses.
God is a pure spirit distinct from the universe that He created. He is not an immanent fire or spirit of fire that permeates creation.
Strong emotions cannot be discarded as evil. Instead, they are an integral part of our human nature. One of the three faculties of our soul is sensibility – along with intelligence and will – which is turned toward capturing, purifying and ordering our sensitive impressions in which emotions are included. Our Lord himself expressed rage in response to the money-lenders in the Temple, manifested joy at the Last Supper by singing the Canticle of Moses, and on numerous occasions expressed a legitimately deep and painful sorrow.
Errors coming from fatalism
Stoicism is inherently flawed, both in its immanent conception of God as a world spirit and in its denial of emotions as legitimate responses.
God is a pure spirit distinct from the universe that He created. He is not an immanent fire or spirit of fire that permeates creation.
Strong emotions cannot be discarded as evil. Instead, they are an integral part of our human nature. One of the three faculties of our soul is sensibility – along with intelligence and will – which is turned toward capturing, purifying and ordering our sensitive impressions in which emotions are included. Our Lord himself expressed rage in response to the money-lenders in the Temple, manifested joy at the Last Supper by singing the Canticle of Moses, and on numerous occasions expressed a legitimately deep and painful sorrow.
Errors coming from fatalism
Suicide became a common practice among stoics when they could not bear their fate
St. Augustine condemns the stoics, both for seeking a state of earthly
happiness and for their acceptance of suicide as a recourse, if living
becomes too incommodious. Any philosophy that holds that natural
suffering is not evil, yet believes that taking one's life is a
legitimate alternative to enduring suffering is contradictory. What kind
of happy life drives one to kill himself? As Catholics, we must
remember that fortitude is a virtue and does not consist simply in
negating emotions. Stoicism was, thus, a pagan philosophical system that
preached apathy based upon the three errors of fatalism, immanentism
and materialism.
The Catholic Church, as we pointed out above, teaches that God is a pure spirit, Who is not substantially immanent in His creation. Man has free will and is not subjected to a blind fatality. Emotions are a part of our nature that should be accepted when the circumstances are appropriate.
Thus, while Stoicism was a relevant philosophy and did have some commendable points, it was rightly set aside to make way for the perfect philosophy of Christianity in which pains and joys are accepted on this earth as a preparation for eternal life, following the steps of Our Lord Jesus Christ, Who taught us by His example the way of the Cross.
The Catholic Church, as we pointed out above, teaches that God is a pure spirit, Who is not substantially immanent in His creation. Man has free will and is not subjected to a blind fatality. Emotions are a part of our nature that should be accepted when the circumstances are appropriate.
Thus, while Stoicism was a relevant philosophy and did have some commendable points, it was rightly set aside to make way for the perfect philosophy of Christianity in which pains and joys are accepted on this earth as a preparation for eternal life, following the steps of Our Lord Jesus Christ, Who taught us by His example the way of the Cross.
- Sources:
- Federico Klimke, Historia de la Filosofia, Barcelona: Editorial Labor, 1947.
- Paul Foulquié, & Raymond Saint-Jean, Dictionnaire de la Langue Philosophique, Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1962. Entry “Stoicisme”
- Vacant, Mangenot Dictionnaire de Theologie Catholique, 1941, entry “Théologies et Philosophies Médiévales”